论我国《消费者权益保护法》修改中的惩罚性赔偿制度的完善
徐海燕;
摘要：
为降低消费者的维权成本和经营者的违法收益、提高消费者的维权收益和经营者的违法成本,本文主张进一步完善《消费者权益保护法》中的惩罚性赔偿制度,对所有惩罚性赔偿均采取"上不封顶、下要保底"的立法态度,大幅提升惩罚性赔偿的倍数,设置最低惩罚性倍数与最低赔偿额中择高赔偿的制度,对欺诈的认定不再苛求经营者的主观故意,也不再苛求消费者的缔约行为与经营者的欺诈行为之间有因果关系。
关键词： 消费者权益;惩罚性赔偿;经营者;消费者
基金项目: 对外经济贸易大学科研创新团队“民事权利保护研究”的资助
通讯作者:
Email:
参考文献：
- [1]Black’s Law Dictionary(6th.Ed.).p.390.
- [2]Ausness,Retribution and Deterrence:The Role of Punitive Damages in Products Liability Litigation,74 Ky.L.J.1,2(1985).
- [3]Norman T.Braslow:The Recognition and Enforcement of Common Law Punitive Damages in a Civil Law System:Some Re-flections on the Japanese Experience,16Ariz.J.Int’l&Comp.Law 285,294(1999).
- [4]98Eng.Rep.489(K.B.1763).
- [5]Jane Mallor&Barry Roberts,Punitive Damages:Toward a Principled Approach,50Hastings L.J.969(1999).
- [6]Steven R.Salbu,Developing Rational Punitive Damages Policies:Beyoned the Constitution,49Fla.L.Rev.247(1992).
- [7]Genay v.Norris,1S.C.L.3,1Bay 6(1784).
- [8]David G.Owen,Punitive Damages in Products Liability Litigation,74,Michigan Law Review 1257,1287(1976).
- [9]Dorsey D.Ellis,Fairness and Efficiency in the Law of Punitive Damages,56Southern California Law Review,1,3(1982).
- [10]John F.Vargo,“The American Rule on Attorney Fee Allocation:The Injured Person's Access to Justice”,42Am.U.L.Rev.1567,1575—1578(1993).)
- [11]王利明.惩罚性赔偿研究[J].中国社会科学,2000(4):112-122.
- [12]谢哲胜.惩罚性赔偿[J].台大法学论从,30卷第1期.
- [13]104III.App.3d1021,433N.E.2d1005(1982).
- [14]100A.D.2d488,474N.Y.S.2d344(1984).
- [15]Black’s Law Dictionary(6th.Ed.).
- [16]103N.J.643,512A.2d466(1986).
- [17]622S.W.2d362(Mo.Ct.App.1981).
- [18]Steven R.Salbu,Developing Rational Punitive Damages Policies:Beyoned the Constitution,49Fla.L.Rev.247,(1992).